School Vaccines Not a Given

Controversy is raging over the benefits and risks of vaccines as the back-to-school rush of physicals begins. Parents receiving letters mandating up-to-date vaccinations in order for their child to attend school need to know their options.

Common misunderstandings prevail. Yes, schools must keep current vaccination records on all of their students. But the law in Michigan, as many other states, also allows a parent or guardian to waive or defer any or all vaccines, and still have their child attend school. This protection has been in place for years and many families elect to use it.

Schools must accept a parent’s notification of this preference, which can be submitted on a State of Michigan Immunization Waiver Form. However, any written notification is allowed by law as long as it is signed by the parent or legal guardian. Prepared forms are available from the Michigan Opposing Mandatory Vaccines website at MomVaccines.org.

Last year, a parent’s inquiry caused Dr. Robert J. Beckman, an osteopathic physician board certified in pediatrics, to again clarify the issue. “I learned that the Michigan Department of Community Health was ‘encouraging’ schools to seek medical exemptions when the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC) vaccination recommendations are not followed, rather than accept a parent’s signed waiver,” Beckman says. “It’s also common for schools to refer parents to the local health department for an ‘approved’ vaccine waiver, and a ‘required’ video that promotes how harmful it is to not vaccinate a child.”

Beckman takes seriously his responsibility to be aware of vaccine efficacy and safety, but knows he cannot rely solely on information supplied by the American Academy of Pediatrics, CDC or vaccine manufacturers. “Conflict of interest is rampant,” counsels Beckman. So he goes to sources like the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC.org) and Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPSonline.org).

And, he advises, “As with any health care issue, good counsel cannot be given based on comfortable ignorance. Make sure you and your health care provider discuss the facts before deciding on any medical care for your child.”

In the end, to vaccinate or not to vaccinate remains a parent’s choice. It’s the job of schools and health care providers to understand the law and parental rights without casting judgment. Every child’s circumstances and health history are individual and deserve an informed, well-considered decision.

Dr. Robert J. Beckman has a private practice at 1820 Oak Avenue in Muskegon. He may be reached at 231-767-3200. 

Source: Originally published in Natural Awakenings West Michigan August 2007 Children's Health issue.